Skip to content
FDIC-Insured - Backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. Government

FHA vs conventional loan: a side-by-side guide to down payment, credit score, and mortgage insurance

The difference between an FHA and a conventional loan is who stands behind it. FHA loans are insured by the federal government, and conventional loans are not. Everything else follows from that. FHA mortgage insurance costs the same at any credit score, and FHA is more flexible on credit. Conventional loans price by credit score and let mortgage insurance end. In general, a higher credit score favors conventional and a lower one favors FHA. Here is the side-by-side comparison.

Home State Bank mortgage teamCrystal Lake, IL · Appleton, WI · NMLS 478452Updated November 19, 20268-minute read

The difference between an FHA and a conventional loan

An FHA loan is insured by the Federal Housing Administration, part of the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). If the borrower defaults, FHA covers the lender's loss. You pay for that protection through a mortgage insurance premium (MIP). Because the government carries the risk, FHA's rules can be more flexible on credit and down payment.

A conventional loan has no government insurance behind it. Most are written to the standards of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the two companies that buy mortgages from lenders. When you put less than 20% down, a private company insures part of the loan instead, and you pay private mortgage insurance (PMI). Home State Bank offers both loan types, so the question is which one costs you less and fits the house.

FHA vs conventional at a glance

FHA figures below come from HUD, and conventional figures are Fannie Mae's published standards. Lenders can be stricter than either agency, so lender requirements vary.

FHA vs conventional loan comparison for 2026 (one-unit home)
FHAConventional
Minimum down payment3.5%, or 10% if your credit score is 500 to 5793% with HomeReady, Home Possible, or a first-time buyer on a standard loan
Credit score floor580 for 3.5% down; 500 with 10% down; not eligible below 500No fixed minimum through Fannie Mae's automated underwriting; 620 for manually underwritten fixed-rate loans
Mortgage insurance cost1.75% upfront, usually financed, plus 0.55% a year with less than 5% down or 0.50% with 5% or more (30-year loans up to $726,200)Monthly PMI with less than 20% down, priced by credit score and down payment
How mortgage insurance endsUnder 10% down: life of the loan. 10% or more down: after 11 yearsOn request at 80% of original value; automatically at 78%
2026 loan limit, baseline areas$541,287$832,750
Debt-to-income ratio (monthly debts divided by monthly income)Manual underwriting: 31% housing and 43% total, up to 40% and 50% with compensating factors (580 score or higher)Up to 50% through automated underwriting; 36% manual, or 45% with strong credit and reserves
Property conditionMust meet HUD's minimum property requirements: safe, sound, and secureSafety, soundness, and structural problems must be repaired; minor deferred maintenance generally need not be
OccupancyPrimary residence; move in within 60 days and intend to stay at least a yearPrimary residence, second home, or investment property
Seller-paid closing costsUp to 6% of the sales price3% with less than 10% down, 6% with 10% to under 25% down, 9% with 25% or more (primary or second home)

How your credit score changes the answer

This is the center of the FHA vs conventional decision. On a conventional loan, two prices move with your credit score. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac charge fees based on a grid of credit score and loan-to-value ratio (LTV, the loan amount divided by the home's value), and those fees feed into the pricing a lender can offer. Private mortgage insurers work the same way: the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) notes that PMI rates vary by down payment and credit score.

FHA mortgage insurance is priced differently. According to the CFPB, it costs the same no matter your credit score, with only a small difference tied to the down payment. So two buyers looking at the same house can get opposite answers. A buyer with a high score often pays less with a conventional loan. A buyer with a lower score or a smaller down payment often pays less with FHA.

FHA MIP for life versus PMI you can cancel

How long you pay matters as much as how much. Under HUD's premium schedule, a 30-year FHA loan with less than 10% down carries the annual premium for the whole loan term. Put 10% or more down and it ends after 11 years.

Conventional PMI falls under a federal law, the Homeowners Protection Act, which covers single-family primary residences. You can ask your servicer in writing to cancel PMI once your balance reaches 80% of the home's original value, meaning the lower of the purchase price or the appraised value when you bought. You need a good payment history and no second mortgage, and the servicer can ask for evidence that the value has not fallen. If you never ask, PMI must end when the balance is scheduled to reach 78%, provided you are current, or once the loan passes the midpoint of its schedule (15 years on a 30-year loan).

FHA borrowers have an exit too: refinancing from FHA to conventional. A conventional loan generally needs no PMI once you have 20% equity, so many FHA borrowers refinance at that point. A refinance is a new loan with its own closing costs and whatever rate the market offers that day, so run the numbers first.

A hypothetical example: same house, two credit profiles

Take a $300,000 home with 5% down. The FHA side of the math is set by HUD: 1.75% upfront, usually added to the loan, and 0.50% a year at exactly 5% down. The conventional side depends on the PMI quote for your credit profile, so the table uses two invented quotes.

For the first buyer, conventional costs less each month, avoids the upfront premium, and the insurance can come off later. For the second, FHA's monthly premium is about half the PMI quote, although the upfront premium adds nearly $5,000 to the balance and the premium does not end. Interest rates would differ too, so the real comparison is two Loan Estimates (the standard disclosure of rate, payment, and closing costs) side by side.

Hypothetical example only: $300,000 home, 5% down on each loan. FHA figures follow HUD's premium schedule. The PMI amounts are invented round numbers, not quotes. Interest rates are left out on purpose.
FHAConventional, higher credit scoreConventional, lower credit score
Base loan amount$285,000$285,000$285,000
Upfront mortgage insuranceAbout $4,988, added to the loanNoneNone
Loan balance at closingAbout $289,988$285,000$285,000
Monthly mortgage insuranceAbout $119$80 (hypothetical)$240 (hypothetical)

3% down conventional options: HomeReady and Home Possible

FHA is not the only low down payment route. Fannie Mae's HomeReady and Freddie Mac's Home Possible both allow 3% down on a one-unit primary residence. Both limit the income used to qualify to 80% of the area median income (AMI) for the property's location. HomeReady does not require you to be a first-time buyer, although a homeownership education course is required when every occupying borrower is one.

Both also call for less mortgage insurance coverage than a standard loan when you put less than 10% down (25% on HomeReady instead of 30% or 35%), and less coverage generally means a lower PMI premium. If your income is over the limit, Fannie Mae still allows 3% down on a standard loan when at least one borrower is a first-time homebuyer, meaning no home ownership in the past three years.

2026 FHA and conforming loan limits in McHenry County and the Fox Valley

Loan size can settle the question before credit does. For 2026, McHenry County in Illinois and Outagamie, Winnebago, and Calumet counties in Wisconsin all sit at the national baseline: $832,750 for a one-unit conforming conventional loan and $541,287 for FHA, which HUD sets at 65% of the conforming limit. A loan above $541,287 here is outside FHA, and above $832,750 it becomes a jumbo loan. The Federal Housing Finance Agency usually announces the next year's limit in late November, and the 2027 limits have not been published as of this writing.

The house matters too. An FHA appraiser has to report whether the home meets HUD's minimum property requirements and must flag defective paint on homes built before 1978. Required repairs generally have to be finished before closing. A conventional appraisal also reports condition, and anything affecting safety, soundness, or structural integrity must be repaired, but minor deferred maintenance generally does not have to be. On an older home near the Woodstock Square or in central Appleton, that difference can affect which loan works for the house.

Is FHA or conventional better for you?

Neither loan is better for everyone. The pattern looks like this.

When you apply with us, a loan officer can price FHA and conventional on the same house so you can compare the total monthly payment and the cash to close, not just the rate. Approval depends on your full application, and nothing here is a commitment to lend.

  • FHA tends to fit: a lower credit score or a higher debt-to-income ratio, on a primary residence that meets HUD's property standards
  • Conventional tends to fit: a higher credit score, a plan to drop mortgage insurance as you build equity, or a loan amount above the FHA limit
  • Conventional is the only one of the two for a second home or an investment property
  • HomeReady or Home Possible is worth pricing if your qualifying income is at or under 80% of area median income

Questions people ask

Is FHA or conventional better for first-time buyers?
It depends mostly on your credit score and down payment. FHA mortgage insurance costs the same at every credit score, so it often works out cheaper for buyers with lower scores. Conventional pricing and PMI improve as your score rises, and PMI can be canceled later. Neither loan is limited to first-time buyers.
What credit score do you need for an FHA loan vs a conventional loan?
HUD allows FHA financing with 3.5% down at a score of 580 or higher, and with 10% down from 500 to 579. Fannie Mae sets no fixed minimum for loans approved through its automated underwriting system and requires 620 for manually underwritten fixed-rate loans. Lenders set their own minimums, and many conventional programs start at 620.
Does FHA mortgage insurance ever go away?
Only in some cases. If you put down 10% or more, the annual premium ends after 11 years. With less than 10% down it lasts for the life of the loan unless you refinance out of FHA.
Can I use an FHA loan for a second home or rental property?
Generally no. FHA requires at least one borrower to move in within 60 days and intend to live in the home for at least a year. Conventional loans are available for primary residences, second homes, and investment properties.
Can I refinance from an FHA loan to a conventional loan?
Yes, if you qualify for the new loan. Borrowers often do it once they have about 20% equity, because a conventional loan at that point generally carries no mortgage insurance. Weigh the closing costs and the new rate against the monthly savings first.

This article is general information, not financial, tax, or legal advice, and not a commitment to lend. Program terms, limits, and rates change; confirm current figures with a loan officer. Home State Bank, N.A. NMLS 478452. Member FDIC · Equal Housing Lender.

Next step

Ready to talk to a lender who can actually decide?

Start the application online, or call and ask for the mortgage department. Either way, a real human in Crystal Lake or Appleton takes it from there.